May
Diversion – Why it Matters and Why it Doesn’t
It happened again today. A client bragged to you that she just picked up a couple of bottles of the shampoo you were trying to sell her at Target. On sale. Wonderful. Diversion is a nasty word in the beauty industry, and the numbers are staggering. Of the $29 billion spent on professional beauty products last year, over $800 million were spent on diverted products. I hear salon owner’s concerns about diversion on a daily basis, so I thought I’d take a minute to discuss what the manufacturers are saying, how diversion really affects your business and give you a couple of strategies to combat it.
The manufacturer’s story – Professional product manufacturers would like us to believe that all diverted product comes from guys in vans who drive around all day collecting case lots of shampoo from unsuspecting salon owners at 10% above cost. While some diversion may occur this way, a much larger chunk comes from some distributors who are selling truckloads out the back door. In an effort to stop this practice, manufacturers have demanded accountability from distributors, including encrypted coding on bottles which can track all bottles back to the distributor that sold them. While they are making some progress, manufacturers have been slow to respond, and the many income channels that diversion has created will make this an almost impossible problem to solve. Manufacturers are now spending millions of dollars fighting diversion, but notable results will be slow to see – it takes 6-9 months for a diverted product to appear on a retail shelf after leaving the manufacturer.
How Diversion Affects Your Business – For many years the industry fought the proliferation of “Phantom salons”, places like Ulta that have a dusty chair or two in the back so that they can sell professional beauty products like a real salon. Now the greater evil is seeing the lines that you’ve so generously sold your clients on and taught them to use being sold on an endcap at Target. Diversion is clearly a breach of trust between you and the manufacturer that you hitched your horse to – the one who promised that their products would “be sold in professional salons only”. But an annoying as the problem is, I don’t actually think that diversion hurts your business any more than grocery store haircolor, Pantene or herbal remedies hurt your business. Diversion has created competition for your customer’s dollars, but that competition was always there. Other competitors include other stylists in your own salon, every other salon in town, people who buy a bottle of wine and decide that they are going to color each other’s hair and men who shave their heads. All have the potential to take money out of your pocket. It is your responsibility is to make sure that your clients are leaving your salon with the products that they need to keep their hair looking great. If so, they have no reason to buy shampoo at Safeway, or color their own hair or shave their heads.
What can you do about it -
- Many of my salon owners are voting with their dollars and choosing not to do business with manufacturers that don’t keep their lines clean. Simply put, there are companies that have a diversion problem and there are ones who don’t. Investing your money in partnerships with companies who may not be as well known, but whose products can’t be found in every salon in America is a retail strategy that makes sense. Exclusivity gives you an advantage simply because products that are harder to find ensure that clients must return to your salon to continue buying the products they love.
- Give your clients a reason to stay loyal. Create a rewards program, basing it on total dollars spent or the number of products purchased on a punchcard that lets your clients accumulate points until they get something free. I have one client that offers her customers $1 off each product they purchase if they bring the empty back in. You wouldn’t think that $1 would be much of an incentive, but her retail business is thriving. Be creative and find something that ensures that your clients are buying their retail from you.
Diversion isn’t going away, but it doesn’t have to hurt your business either. Take a stand and do business with companies that support you and your salon. Your business will thrive and you won’t have to worry about diversion again.




